How do we know when God is leading us in a certain direction, especially when we’re unsure what decision to make?

A wise man once told me that God has three kinds of will for our lives.  When we are faced with choices and we are trying to live in God’s will we should bear those three kinds of will in mind.  So the types of will God has for us are: His express will, His permissive will, and His noncommittal will.

God’s express will consists in those things that God definitely wants us to choose in order for us to live within His will.  His permissive will consists of those things we can choose that do not interfere with His express will but may make living in God’s will more difficult or less productive.  God’s noncommittal will consists in those things which do not touch upon God’s express will.  Those are the things that truly don’t matter in life.  In my own life, I have found that my occasional refusal to choose to live within God’s express will has meant that my own happiness and my purpose are delayed in their coming to fruition.  In that case, God’s will is deferred until such time as we come to understand what God desires for us or until such time as we stop our rebellion and agree to pursue His path for our life.

Let me make a point here.  God is a Gentleman.  He will not talk over you and He will not insist on having His way.  Nor will He coerce you into doing what He wants you to do.  God desires our cooperation, not just our obedience.  If your mind is carrying on a constant monologue, never stopping to hear what God has to say, you will never hear what He has to say.  You are obviously not interested in hearing from God if all you do is tell Him what you think. 

At the same time, it is equally harmful if you agree to God’s plan for you and then immediately put qualifications and limits on your obedience.  Imagine saying to God, “yes, I know that you want me to marry this particular person, and I will do that, but we have to live in this kind of neighborhood and he or she must fit in with my group of friends.” 

To the person who asked this question.  Please rest easier in the knowledge that every person who has pursued ordination or has sought entry into a lifetime commitment as a monk or a nun has gone through the same ordeal that you are undergoing.  You are not alone.  Others have suffered the same questions that you have.

Rest assured that God knows you better than you even know yourself.  He loves you better than you love yourself.  What he wants for you is better than what you want for yourself.  Usually the biggest issue is that your faith in yourself is larger than your faith in Him.  And that is a major hindrance to your obedience.  You must be willing to place yourself at His complete disposal.  Not knowing where He is leading you, you must be led.